Monday, March 30, 2009
Emin versus Creed
Same question. Intelligent answers get extra credit. Who is the best of these two contemporary artists? Emin bares her soul here: http://www.tracey-emin.co.uk/ and Creed lets us into his mind-closet here: http://martincreed.com/. Both of these artists demand some time to be spent with them to truly understand them. It might be worth a google to see what other people have had to say about them. WARNING: Emin's website contains rude words and is intentionally shocking. Do not proceed if easily offended.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Emin has given up on trying to put her best foot forward in fine art, and realising that she can provoke reaction by writing about her vagina's behaviour and endeavours, has managed to dig her nails into the modern art scene.
ReplyDeleteI really don't find her as shocking as critics make her out to be, although through her art she has made some effective points that raise awareness about life after being raped and abused and all that jazz.
She's also put forward the issues regarding society's censored sexual customs and taboo, but this means she's living off a topic that is just so overused and blah. Every second girl out there is just as angsty and as mentally screwed as she is (or maybe it's just the ones I'm friends with), but they conceal it or only release it in subtle ways. Emin blurts it to the world in the most immature way possible, and I think people are only freaked out by her lack of respect towards her own reputation – not her actual artworks. Emin is the work of art herself. She has, constructively, given up on herself and will go down in history as that crazy chick with the bad attitude, but hey, at least she’ll go down in history – that’s probably more than I’ll ever accomplish.
Creed’s wardrobe contents make me giggle.
Yeah, he’s just like Emin in the way that he’s given up on practising fine art, but at least he has a good sense of humour about it. I don’t think he’s out to get too much attention like Emin is. His work is so simplistic, it’s refreshing. There’s hardly any emotional baggage to his work, and he generally has an optimistic aura about him. He just makes you look at the smaller details in life... like blue tack, and rolled up bits of paper... all the bits and pieces you would normally overlook as being visually pleasant.
I think this is just wonderful >>
http://martincreed.com/works/images/work200
Oh and.... ‘I like his things... aaaa... lot.’ (See what I did there?)
These two remind me of a contrast of characters I’ve seen walking around on the street. Once I witnessed a bum dressed as a romantic pirate -- he wore a frilly shirt and leather pants, drank cheap red wine out of a fancy bottle and kept a smile on his face. Another bum I came across sat in a heap drinking whisky, yelled abuse at everyone walking past and occasionally indecently exposed himself.
I see Creed as the first bum, he makes life fun for himself and others, and everyone benefits from that. Emin is like the second bum, who nobody can reason with without getting a fistful of hate.
I’d say Creed is the ‘better’ one, if there is such a thing in this politically correct life as being better. He’s just happier, and that’s naturally appealing to most other humans.
I mean:
ReplyDeleteI think this is just wonderful >>
http://martincreed.com/works/workno200.html
It's Creed all the way for me, maybe i didn't get Emin but I just like the ramdom that is Creeds work maybe there is more to it I don't know but I liked the pictures of random objects the scrunched up ball of paper for example. The women chucking up on a canvas.....genious.
ReplyDeleteI don't know what it is, but I know what I likes! Chicks vomiting on a canvas seems a little strange, even to a guy like me!
ReplyDeleteBut hey...a person who can scrunch up a piece of paper and become famous for being sick gets my vote.
I can't say I'd go as to the length of VOMITING on a canvas though.
Nothin personal...just not my style.
Heeheeheeheeheeeeee!
i like emin, because her artwork is different and i like different work like hers, yes some of its disgusting but its well done because shes not affraid to express her self where as creeds work isnt that good some of it looks like a five year old did it eg. workno 539 its just scribbles on a piece of paper and frankily i think its a waste of paper and spewing on a canvas is quite gross i think hes emotionally constipated. but emin would have to do it for me i like the way she thinks. :)
ReplyDeleteEmin's work is gutsy and revealing, but can also be gentle and meditative if you look at the right piece, in the right way. Most people seem to think that Emin has created many of her pieces just to cause a stir and get attention, and although I think this is part of it, it does not describe the entirety of her works, or their potential.
ReplyDeleteIt seems to me that the only way Emin can create art is to involve herself in it. ( Similarly to Landy's struggles). I do kind of agree with dirty + sweet that Emin's work drags along her past and emotional baggage with it-but without this, would the work still be hers'? Would it still be, as she claims to make, "autobiographical art"?
And then there are sweet pieces such as this-http://www.tracey-emin.co.uk/emin-articles/tracey-emin-brick-lane.htm.
They are almost newspaper articles about snippets of her life, so you can experience for a brief moment what it feels like for her to do whatever it is she is doing.
The famous Australian poet Judith Wright once asked herself-
"What use is poetry?". She came up with the response:
"...to express and exemplify the feeling which brought the poem into existence; that is, to help with the process of understanding one's life and its meaning. For the reader, it can help in the same way. That is what art is for."
I believe that Emin's works do this-perhaphs in an abrasive, rude, self-centered and immature fashion, but with the conviction and faith of someone who just wants to share their life and their art. Perhaphs her immaturity, as distasteful as it is, is the most interesting and defining part of her art-and herself.
Firstly, I love the entrance to Martin's website. It is like getting a new toy-or discovering something really cool. That's why I was kinda disappointed with some of his artworks.
The ones I like most are the ones which make you appreciate things you wouldn't usually appreciate. Like the blu-tac, for instance, and the multitude of colored tiles. I was always fascinated by color and pattern-on walls, tiles, anything. So the tile exhibition was one I found really appealing.
I found the artworks involving the neon words, signposts and words painted on walls thought-provoking, but in the end meaningless. I did not understand any of them, and there was no compulsion or curiosity generated to do so.
In the end, it was Emin who did it for me-her emotional approach to art was something I found far more appealing than the simple and although occasionally appealing, in the end meaningless works by Creed.