Who is the best out of Michael Landy and David Shrigley?
Check out Landy here: http://video.aol.com/video-detail/michael-landy/2178214144 and here: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GnTCZFyzkvY&feature=PlayList&p=8B2C4752293E383F&playnext=1&playnext_from=PL&index=40
And Shrigley here: http://www.davidshrigley.com/
Thursday, March 26, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Both are complete nutjobs and are full of questionable taste, but I'd have to go with Shrigley if I had to choose the 'best' of the two.
ReplyDeleteLandy is just frustrating, so he is shoved into second place in this duel. He makes me want to throw stones in his direction with all my girlish might, and yell like an old bag at his videos; "No, don't do that, you don't have to do that, that is silly."
Surprisingly, my laptop is still in top-draw condition after watching both youtubeydoobies.
I feel a bit more at ease viewing a
Shrigley piece. Insane, yes, but also thought provoking. His animations are like little stories that can really hold your interest, even though the true meaning of them is sometimes confusing, cryptic, and more than likely to go over your head, leaving you feeling a bit muddled and vulnerable. You can still find it amusing even if you don't understand what is going on, but of course I understand all of his pieces, because I understand everything ever, and I am a genius and you should all grovel.
Shrigley won me over when I heard the line "I want to be water soluble so that when I go water skiing and fall off, I will dissolve before the sharks can eat me"
(http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kHKIEe16YNk)
Wonderful.
That is a brilliant line. In Landy's defence, he destroyed everything he had I think so that we don't have to. Just like jesus. I can see why he would come to that need to purge based on what he would see every day coming out of the new world art factory. 'He died for all our sins'. What did Shrigley ever do except make us smile, but then perhaps making us smile is a greater deed than saving our souls, whatever a soul might entail...
ReplyDeleteOHOHOH. We can't watch YouTube videos at school.
ReplyDeleteBut based on what I've seen of Shrigley, he has cynical humour which is something I can laugh at.
Or there's something wrong with me if I'm laughing? xD
Being a complete hoarder, I found it hard to watch Landy destroy everything he owned. I just wanted to collect everything myself and add it to the masses of junk stacked around my room, thinking that one day 'it would come in handy.'
ReplyDeleteShrigley's blunt humor is just effed up. Brilliant, but effed up nonetheless. (Jodie is attempting not to swear!) :D
Hell, in one drawing he writes about his insane brother who 'f*cked and killed and ate some animals at the zoo'
(http://www.davidshrigley.com/draw_htmpgs/leotard/2_sibling.html)
Thats my type of art.
I have to admit that i have not seen much of landy's work so this really is one sided for me, though i still think shrigley is a genious It is sort of hope for me that you don't have to be able to draw to create art.
ReplyDeletealso shrigley's work is funny.
ReplyDeleteI like shrigley. He makes me laugh! His cynicism is a hoot!
ReplyDeleteI like to laugh. SO SHRIGLEY...you have my vote. Hee heehee haha haha!
i much prefer shrigley over landy as his artworks much more interesting to read and look at.
ReplyDeleteand he makes me laugh which i like to do.
i think he has a wild imagination which is a great quality to have :)
so go shrigley.
Shrigley certainly is amusing, and has a brilliant imagination to come up with the things he does. But his randomness and directionlessness that permeates his works makes either him look childish, or you feel ignorant for not knowing what he is getting at.
ReplyDeleteMabye it is how imaginative his works are that make his works seem childish to me. Compared with the pains that Landy undergoes in order to create artwork, Shrigley's work seems trivial and immature.
Landy seems to believe he has to undergo some kind of trial or difficulty to produce each artwork, and only seems to be satisfied when this is finished or he has found a solution. It seems to me that he is more inent on him being part of his artwork than his artwork being part of him.
It is this dedication to what he does that makes me respect his efforts more than Shrigleys, although both express very valid points throughout their artwork.